The Brain Pretzel (or: How I Won an Argument About Being Wrong by Admitting I Could Be Wrong)

It started with a simple question. Someone I was talking to kept insisting he was right about something. And not just right. Barely-might-be-wrong right. You know the type. The kind of person who says there’s a very, very, very small chance they could be wrong, which is basically just saying “I’m right” with extra steps and a thesaurus.

Now here’s where it gets really fun. I have this thing I do where I throw out random statistical brain-teasers. Like “there’s a 60 percent chance you’re right 40 percent of the time.” It sounds like it means something. It might. I have no idea. That’s the beauty of it. Neither does anyone else, but everyone will have an opinion about it. And that right there is the whole ADHD experience in a nutshell. Your brain generates something that feels profound, and by the time you try to explain why it’s profound, you’ve already moved on to the next thing that feels profound, and the first thing is just sitting there like “wait, weren’t we doing something?”

So I told him something that has now become my favorite brain pretzel. Here’s the logic. If I admit there’s a possibility I could be wrong, that actually makes me right, because I’m accounting for the margin of error. I’m holding space for the fact that I’m human and I don’t know everything. Meanwhile, someone who says there’s almost no chance they’re not right is wrong by default, because they’ve eliminated the one thing that would make them right, which is the ability to be wrong.

There’s a 60 percent chance he understood that. A 40 percent chance he didn’t. Either way, the odds were never in his favor.

He came back with something like “a small possibility I could possibly be incorrect about something we’re statistically unable to prove.” Buddy. That’s four hedges to say you might be wrong. You just proved my entire point in one sentence. “Small possibility,” “possibly,” “incorrect,” “statistically unable to prove.” That’s not a sentence, that’s a man building a fence around his ego with every word he knows. You could practically watch him tiptoe around the word “wrong” like it was a landmine.

And the best part? He was confused by the whole thing. Which, honestly, just proved the point harder. If you can’t even understand the pretzel, you’re definitely not right about it. You’re just standing outside the pretzel saying “I don’t get it, but I’m pretty sure I’m right about not getting it.”

And that’s the thing about ADHD conversations. They don’t go in a straight line. They go in a pretzel. You start somewhere, you end up somewhere completely different, and somehow the detour was the whole point. Nobody walked into this conversation expecting to crack the code on the philosophy of being wrong. But here we are. And I’m pretty sure I’m right about that.

The thing about having an ADHD brain is you don’t think in arguments. You think in spirals. You start with a point, the point reminds you of a principle, the principle opens up into a theory, and the theory somehow loops back and swallows the original point whole. By the time you’re done, you’ve built this entire logical structure that makes perfect sense to you and absolute zero sense to anyone who wasn’t there for the ride. And trying to explain it after the fact is like trying to describe a dream. You remember how it felt, you remember the big moments, but the connective tissue is just gone.

That’s why this particular conversation was so perfect. It wasn’t just an argument about being wrong. It was an argument about the structure of arguing, inside an argument, that neither of us could fully trace back to its origin. We were two ADHD brains doing what ADHD brains do, which is build a beautiful mess and then stand back and go “wait, that actually makes sense though.”

The funniest part of all of this is that neither of us could even remember what we were originally arguing about. The argument had completely evaporated and we were just fighting about the structure of arguing. Classic ADHD brain. You start in one place, take seven left turns, and suddenly you’re debating the philosophy of being wrong instead of whatever started it. And somehow, I won an argument about being wrong by admitting I could be wrong. That’s the pretzel.

And here’s the scary part. The pretzel holds up. If you can admit you’re wrong, you’re right. If you can’t, you’re wrong. End of story. I dare you to find a hole in it.

There’s a 60 percent chance you will and a 40 percent chance you won’t. Don’t ask me what that means. I have no idea. But it sounds right, and according to my own logic, that’s enough.

But then again, there’s a very, very, very small chance I’m not. 😂